Food for Thought

I'm reading an excellent book called Four Arguments for the Elimination of Television, published in 1978. The author is not a scientist, and never claims to be. He doesn't have answers, just observations and questions that most of us have never even thought to ponder.

There's a section that talks about how television messes with your senses.

Think about it: On your screen, you're watching a shot of two people walking on a distant hillside, yet you can clearly hear what they're saying (when in reality you shouldn't). But what you can't hear are the ambient sounds that your brain would normally expect to hear if you were standing where the scene is being shot. Meanwhile, you're "smelling some chicken roasting in the kitchen and you're drinking a beer."

The author points out that, "Television has attached two of your sensory modes to a distant spot, altered their natural arrangement to each other, but left other aspects of your sensory apparatus at home in present time... [This] takes on importance when we understand that the average person submits to this condition for four hours every day [it's currently five for adults, 4.5 for kids], and while in this state is receiving important information about life. All of the information is narrowed to fit the sensory transmission limits of the medium and distorted by the sensory disconnections in the human.

"One can imagine the emergence of a new psychological syndrome: 'sensory schizophrenia.' The cure will involve exercises to resynchronize wildly confused senses with each other, with the mind, and with the world."

The author's 1978 description of "sensory schizophrenia" immediately made me think of Sensory Processing Disorder (SPD), defined in the book The Out-Of-Sync Child as "a common problem in which the central nervous system misinterprets messages from the senses." So, I tried seeing if any studies had been done on the relationship between TV and SPD. None. Yay science.

What I DID find were several forum threads where parents discuss their SPD child's relationship with TV. In every single thread, over and over, parents mentioned how, from the time their kids were babies, they fed them while the child watched TV. They also mention how at home they have the TV on ALL THE TIME because the adult likes (needs?) background noise.

The author's suggested cure, "exercises to resynchronize wildly confused senses" made me think of Montessori's beautiful Practical Life and Sensorial materials, which engage all of the senses and help re-center (or indeed, "normalize") the child.

Food for thought... (Just don't eat it in front of the TV.)

This post contains affiliate links.

May 1, 2016 12:26pm

By Pilar Bewley

Under

3 min read

3 comments

Food for Thought – Family Love

[…] strawmice06 Uncategorized March 1, 2019 2 Minutes I’m reading an excellent book called Four Arguments for the Elimination of Television, published in 1978. The author is not a scientist, and never claims to be. He doesn’t have answers, just observations and questions that most of us have never even thought to ponder. There’s a section that talks about how television messes with your senses. Think about it: On your screen, you’re watching a shot of two people walking on a distant hillside, yet you can clearly hear what they’re saying (when in reality you shouldn’t). But what you can’t hear are the ambient sounds that your brain would normally expect to hear if you were standing where the scene is being shot. Meanwhile, you’re “smelling some chicken roasting in the kitchen and you’re drinking a beer.” The author points out that, “Television has attached two of your sensory modes to a distant spot, altered their natural arrangement to each other, but left other aspects of your sensory apparatus at home in present time… [This] takes on importance when we understand that the average person submits to this condition for four hours every day [it’s currently five for adults, 4.5 for kids], and while in this state is receiving important information about life. All of the information is narrowed to fit the sensory transmission limits of the medium and distorted by the sensory disconnections in the human. “One can imagine the emergence of a new psychological syndrome: ‘sensory schizophrenia.’ The cure will involve exercises to resynchronize wildly confused senses with each other, with the mind, and with the world.” The author’s 1978 description of “sensory schizophrenia” immediately made me think of Sensory Processing Disorder (SPD), defined in the book The Out-Of-Sync Child as “a common problem in which the central nervous system misinterprets messages from the senses.” So, I tried seeing if any studies had been done on the relationship between TV and SPD. None. Yay science. What I DID find were several forum threads where parents discuss their SPD child’s relationship with TV. In every single thread, over and over, parents mentioned how, from the time their kids were babies, they fed them while the child watched TV. They also mention how at home they have the TV on ALL THE TIME because the adult likes (needs?) background noise. The author’s suggested cure, “exercises to resynchronize wildly confused senses” made me think of Montessori’s beautiful Practical Life and Sensorial materials, which engage all of the senses and help re-center (or indeed, “normalize”) the child. Food for thought… (Just don’t eat it in front of the TV.) This post contains affiliate links. Advertisements Source: https://thefullmontessori.wordpress.com/2016/05/01/food-for-thought/ […]

Read less

Reply over 4 years ago

Food for Thought

Categories

3 comments

Leave a comment